Insurance Companies

  • Home
  • Insurance Companies
Pagetitleicon

Use the Glovebox app for easy access to your access your policy documents & ID cards, pay a bill, and start a claim account all at your fingertips

Our job is to see that your claim is handled quickly and fairly and that you are never out of the loop. Practices and procedures vary somewhat depending on the type of insurance and the insurance company, but you let us worry about that. In most cases we can let you know well in advance what to expect and will be able to make sure that everything is on track. If you ever need us we’re just a phone call away: (414) 768-8100

To better assist you, the following carriers have 24 hour direct claim reporting services available. Prior to calling, please have your policy number and claim details available for the claims adjuster. The insurance carrier will forward a copy of your claim report to our office. Also, if we can assist you in any way, please do not hesitate to contact us or call us at your convenience at (414) 768-8100.

AAA

Parent Company: Auto Club Group
Year Founded:1893
Home Office: Dearborn, MI
General Phone Number:
(800) 222-6424
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 723-0220
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 677-0777
Billing Auto
Billing Boat
Billing Home
Billing Motorcycle
Billing Umbrella
Billing Membership

Acuity

Parent Company: Acuity Group
Year Founded:1925
Home Office: Sheboygan, WI
General Phone Number:
(920) 458-9131
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 242-7666
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 242-7666 x4
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Allstate

Parent Company: Allstate Insurance Group
Year Founded:1931
Home Office: Northbrook, IL
General Phone Number:
(847) 402-5000
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
800-255-7828
Commercial Auto:
(800) 366-3495
Commercial Property or Liability:
(800) 359-1000
Life:
(800) 366-3495
Personal Auto and Home and Commercial Auto:
(800) 255-7828
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 901-1732
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

American Modern Insurance

Parent Company: American Modern Insurance Group
Home Office: Cincinnati, OH
General Phone Number:
(513) 943-7200
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 375-2075
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 543-2644
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

American Strategic Insurance

Parent Company: ASI Assurance
Year Founded:1931
Home Office:St. Petersburg, FL
General Phone Number:
(727) 821-8765
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(866) 274-5677
Flood:
(866) 511-0793
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Auto-Owners Insurance

Parent Company: Auto-Owners Insurance Group
Year Founded:1916
Home Office: Lansing, MI
General Phone Number:
(517) 323-1200
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(888) 252-4626
Commercial Auto:
(800) 288-8740
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 901-1732
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Badger Mutual Insurance Company

Year Founded:1871
Home Office: Milwaukee, WI
General Phone Number:
(847) 402-5000
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 837-7833
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 837-7833
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Berkley Classic

Parent Company: A. W. Berkley Company
Year Founded:1967
General Phone Number:
(800) 603-3330
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(855) 216-6930
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 603-3330
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Dairyland

Parent Company: Sentry Insurance Group
Year Founded:1904
Home Office:Stevens Point, WI
General Phone Number:
(800) 334-0090
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 526-4252
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 334-0090
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Ellington Mutual Insurance Company

Parent Company: Progressive Insurance Group
Year Founded:1878
Home Office:Hortonville, WI
General Phone Number:
(920) 779-4515
Claim Information
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Payments:
Go to Website (Claims Page)

Foremost Insurance Group

A member of the Farmers Insurance Group of Companies®, Foremost Insurance Group ("Foremost")
Year Founded:1952
Home Office: Caledonia, Michigan
Claim Information
Claim phone number 800-527-3907
24-Hour Towing and Roadside Assistance: Motor home, travel trailer, fifth-wheel, motorcycle 800-554-6678

Billing Information
Billing phone number
800-532-4221
Monday – Friday 9AM to 8PM ET Automated Phone System: 24/7

Grange Insurance

Parent Company: Grange Mutual Casualty Pool
Home Office: Columbus, OH
General Phone Number:
(800) 422-0550
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 445-3030
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 425-1100
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Germantown Mutual Insurance Company

Home Office: Germantown, WI
General Phone Number:
(262) 251-6680
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 236-4642
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 236-4642
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Hagerty Insurance

Home Office: Traverse City, MI
General Phone Number:
(877) 922-9701
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 385-0274
Catlin Boat Claims:
(800) 762-2628
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(877) 922-9701
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Website Services:

Manage your policy online


Hastings Mutual Insurance Company

Year Founded:1885
Home Office:Hastings, MI
General Phone Number:
(800) 442-8277
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 442-8277
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Hanover Insurance Company

Parent Company: Hanover Insurance Group Property Casualty Companies
Home Office: Worcester, MA
General Phone Number:
(508) 853-7200
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 628-0250
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 573-1187
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

IMT Insurance

Parent Company: IMT Insurance
Year Founded:1884
Home Office:West Des Moines, IA
General Phone Number:
(800) 274-3531
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 274-3531
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Integrity Insurance

Parent Company: Grange Mutual Casualty Group
Year Founded:1933
Home Office: Appleton, WI
General Phone Number:
(920) 734-4511
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 445-3030
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(888) 699-9182
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Kemper Insurance

Parent Company: Unitrin, Inc.
Year Founded:1926
Home Office: Jacksonville, FL
General Phone Number:
(877) 252-7878
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(888) 252-2799
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(877) 488-7488
Website Services:
View, print, and pay your bill; print an auto ID card.
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Liberty Mutual Insurance

Parent Company: Liberty Mutual Insurance
Year Founded:1912
Home Office: Boston, Massachusetts
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(833) 218-0222
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(833) 218-0222
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Madison Mutual Insurance Company

Year Founded:1893
Home Office: Chittenango, NY
General Phone Number:
(315) 687-3211
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(315) 687-3211
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Mt. Morris Mutual Insurance Company

Year Founded:1875
Home Office: Coloma, Wisconsin
General Phone Number:
(877) 228-5541
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(877) 228-4199
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Nationwide

Parent Company: Nationwide Group
Home Office: Columbus OH
General Phone Number:
(877) 669-6877
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 421-3535
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(888) 891-0267
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Openly Insurance

Year Founded:2017

General Phone Number:
857.990.9080 x1 or 0
Click here to email services
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
888.808.4842
Claims:
Click here to email claims
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
857.990.9080 x2
Click here to email billing

PIE Insurance

Year Founded:2017
Home Office:Denver, CO
General Phone Number:
855-858-5988
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
844-581-0828
Claims:
Click here to email claims
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
855-880-0204
Click here to email billing

Progressive Insurance

Parent Company: Progressive Insurance Group
Year Founded:1937
Home Office: Mayfield Village, OH
General Phone Number:
(440) 461-5000
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 776-4737
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 876-5581
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Pekin Insurance Company

Parent Company: Pekin Insurance Group
Year Founded:1921
General Phone Number:
(309) 346-1161
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(888) 735-4611
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 322-0160
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Partners Mutual Insurance

Parent Company: Penn National Insurance
Year Founded:1931
General Phone Number:
(262) 798-5050
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 551-5151
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(855) 329-5686
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Racine County Mutual Insurance Company

Year Founded:1876
Home Office: Franksville, WI
General Phone Number:
(800) 297-3617
Billing Information
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

State Auto Insurance Companies

Parent Company: State Auto Insurance Companies
Year Founded:1921
Home Office: Columbus, OH
General Phone Number:
(614) 464-5000
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
800-255-7828
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 444-9950 x5118
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

SECURA Insurance

Home Office:Appleton, WI
General Phone Number:
(920) 739-3161
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 828-7047
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 236-8700
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
More Information:

SECURA offers the products and services policyholders need to feel secure at home, work, play, and in between.

Safeco Insurance

Parent Company: Liberty Mutual Insurance
Home Office: Seattle, WA
General Phone Number:
(206) 545-5000
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
800-255-7828
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(888) 723-3260
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Society Insurance

Year Founded:1931
Home Office: Fond du Lac, WI
General Phone Number:
(888) 576-2438
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(888) 576-2438
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(888) 576-2438
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

Selective Insurance Group

Parent Company: Selective Insurance Group
Year Founded:1926
Home Office: Branchville, NJ
General Phone Number:
(973) 948-3000
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(866) 455-9969
Bond claims:
(800) 777-9656
Fax (New Losses):
(877) 352-6541
Fax (Workers' Comp):
(877) 352-6860
Flood:
(877) 348-0552
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(888) 974-7400
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

The Hartford

Year Founded:1810
Home Office:Hartford, CT
General Phone Number:
(860) 547-5000
Claim Information
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 243-5860
Auto, Home:
(800) 243-5860
Business:
(800) 327-3636
Flood:
(800) 787-5677
Glass-Only Auto Claims:
(800) 892-8484
Workers' Compensation Claims:
(800) 327-3636
Billing Information
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Billing Phone Number (Individuals):
(800) 624-5578
Billing Phone Number (Business):
(866) 467-8730

Travelers

Parent Company: Travelers Group
Home Office:Hartford, CT
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(800) 252-4633
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Auto, Home, Personal Property and Boat Claims:
(800) 252-4633
Boat/Yacht:
(800) 772-4482
Business Insurance Claims:
(800) 238-6225
Construction Claims:
(877) 828-4132
Flood:
(800) 505-0193
National Accounts Claims:
(800) 832-7839
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number (Individuals):
(877) 872-8737
Billing Phone Number (Business):
(800) 252-2268
Payments (Individuals):
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Payments (Business):
Go to Website (Bill Pay)
Services:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

West Bend Mutual Insurance Company

Home Office: West Bend, WI
General Phone Number:
(262) 334-5571
Claim Information
Claim Phone Number:
(877) 922-5246
Claims:
Go to Website (Claims Page)
Billing Information
Billing Phone Number:
(800) 236-5002
Payments:
Go to Website (Bill Pay)

BWO will be closed Thanksgiving Day and the Friday following Thanksgiving

Skip to content